OP ED A Reminder: The Other Side of Farm Murders in South Africa

The last time somebody saw Tebogo Ndlovu was on 2 August 2017. Tebogo and two friends were on a farm in Mooinooi, North West Province, when he was shot in the leg by a farmer for apparently stealing a few oranges… writes Nigel Branken in a post which has gone viral, and for which he has given kind permission to be republished here.

tebogo ndlovu
Tebogo Ndlovu

His two friends, fearing for their lives, helped Tebogo to flee, but had to leave him behind when they could not lift him over a fence. When they looked back they saw the person who shot Tebogo standing next to him.

His mother went to the police to report the incident, but it was only after the Makajane community blocked the N4 highway, 20 days later, that the police started to take action.

tebogo ndlovu
Tebogo Ndlovu’s mother

It is alleged that the farmer’s son, Matthew Benson, took Tebogo’s body and fed it to crocodiles on his crocodile farm to hide the evidence of his crimes. Police have found blood stains matching Tebogo’s blood, and cartridges matching Benson’s 9mm pistol were found close to where the shooting took place. Further blood stains were found on Benson’s bakkie. Tebogo’s body has yet to be found.

tebogo ndlovu
Matthew Benson

If it had not been for the protest actions of this local community, shutting down the N4, it is unlikely that Tebogo’s murder or dissapearance would have been investigated.

This incident does not stand alone. A similar incident happened earlier this year in Coligny, when farmers Pieter Doorewaard and Phillip Schutte were accused of killing Matlhomola Jonas Mosweu for allegedly stealing sunflowers.

Then, just this last week, we had the widely publicized case where Theo Jackson and Willem Oosthuizen were given various sentences for assault with intent to cause grievous bodily harm, intimidation and attempted murder for forcing Rethabile Mlotshwa into a coffin and threatening to set it alight. Over the years extensive evidence of atrocities committed against black workers on white-owned farms has consistently been uncovered.

It is into this context that I have been reflecting on the call by some white farmers and white South Africans for us to wear black on Monday to remember “farm murders” (and by “farm murders”, they refer to white farmers murdered). The irony of calling an event “black” Monday to commemorate “white pain” when the most common pain in reality remains “black pain” points to the agenda of the event organizers.

20 years into our democracy and we are as unequal as ever. Arrable farm land predominantly remains in the hands of white South Africans. Farm workers, who are almost exclusively black, remain some of the most exploited and vulnerable workers in our country.

Parliament’s select committee on economic and business development recently visited farms in the Free State and found child labour practices on the farms, rotten meat being fed to workers while fresh meat was given to lions‚ and children of labourers, as young as three, sleeping in unhealthy plastic stalls. Studies repeatedly show farm workers not able to provide adequate nutrition for their families. Racist and exploitative labour practices are rampant across the country.

It is into this context that a narrative has been created that there is an onslaught against white farmers and that they are the most vulnerable in South Africa. Despite Afriforum and others taking to social media to tell us of a so called “white-genocide” and new “swart-gevaar”; (black-danger), this allegation has been fact checked and repeatedly debunked.

Yes there are white farmers who are victims of crime, and yes the murders are often brutal, but these are not the only murders and white farmers are not even the most likely to fall victim to violent crime.

In addition, the pictures we are fed on our social media feed are anecdotal at best and often shared to stir up racially based fear and create a false narrative. Sometimes the pictures we see are not even of farm murders. Just last month, a right winger posted pictures on my Facebook feed of a Charles Manson murder claiming it was a farm attack.

Despite there being a higher incidence of farm murders on white farmers than murders in the general population, black South Africans are still more likely to fall victim to violent crime in South Africa. On Monday, some farmers are telling us to all stop and be concerned about a certain small group of victims… white victims…

If you are surprised at the backlash to this request, perhaps understanding the context will help. In South Africa, white lives have always been prioritized, white lives have always mattered more. It is no wonder people are outraged by this call.

If South Africa is going to move forward in any way, Tebogo Ndlovu’s life must matter too. Dignity on the farms for all farm workers must matter more than it does now. The true measure of our ability to value humanity is not measured in how we protect the most privileged citizens but in the efforts we make to defend the rights of the most vulnerable.

I will not be wearing black on Monday, not because I don’t have compassion for white farmers, but because I stand with all living and working on farms and with all victims of the greatest source of violence in South Africa… the violence of racism.

The main questions I will continue discussing with my family and friends on Monday remain…
– how we build a new South Africa free from the scourge of our racist past?
– What role do I play in this as a white privileged South African?
– How can my life be a sign of hope that a different South Africa, an equal South Africa, a just South Africa is possible?

At the center of these discussions will continue to be discussions on Land and Wealth and how this become more evenly distributed – discussions on what restitution looks like. I will continue reflecting on what my personal responsibility in this is.

South Africa will not live in peace until we find a way to practice justice. #FarmMurders

By Nigel Branken

The last time somebody saw Tebogo Ndlovu was on 2 August 2017. Tebogo and two friends were on a farm in Mooinooi, North…

Posted by Nigel Branken on Saturday, October 28, 2017


Black First Land First Calls on Black People to Boycott #BlackMonday

Black First Land First (BLF) has called on black people to not wear black on Monday.

“White farmers are not special, in fact, if you wear black do it to mourn the thousands of farm workers who are still slaves on farms. White farmers are racist, cruel land thieves who don’t deserve our sympathy,” the organisation said in a statement today.

The claimed it’s a “lie” that white farmers feed the nation.

“Half the South African population is without food security. White farmers poison the nation with GMOs. They produce for profit and don’t care for the health of the nation.

“White farmers have turned farms into zones of violence against black people. Farm workers are killed by farmers every day from Coligny to Mpumalanga where we saw them put our brother, Victor Mlotshwa, in a coffin. The farms are a dangerous and sad place for our people.”

BLF called on the government to protect farm workers by expropriating the land of white farmers “without compensation”.