The ANC government is “making the people of South Africa pay back the money that they [the ANC] have stolen”, claimed Mmusi Maimane after Wednesday Budget Speech was delivered in Parliament by Finance Minister Malusi Gigaba.
The Democratic Alliance (DA) Leader said the 1% increase in VAT and the fuel levy will see the cost of food and travel increase significantly. “The poor will be hardest hit,” he claimed.
Others – including Azania Matiwane, Deputy Chairperson of Black Wealth Foundation – argued it is not the poor who will be hardest hit as they mainly depend on milk and bread (and basic necessities including zero-rated food items are exempted). It is the middle-income and rich who will feel the most impact, he claimed.
Maimane said of the budget announcements, that “instead of taking action to reduce expenditure, Gigaba has introduced proposals for cost cutting that are going to reduce service delivery – Human settlement infrastructure will see a R 7,2 billion reduction, & education infrastructure a R3,6 billion reduction.”
He said the budget “protects the civil servants’ bloated salaries and bonuses, at the cost of poor South Africans.”
The DA’s Deputy Shadow Minister of Finance, Alf Lees, added that the announcements are nothing less than a “massive body blow to poor South Africans”, the repercussions of which will be to dampen economic growth and fail to create much-needed jobs.
“The VAT increase of 1 percentage point is a smack in the face for the millions of South Africans who face a daily battle to put food on the table. This increase, combined with the new fuel levy increase, will force poor South Africans to pay more for basic goods, services and transport.
“Instead of taking decisive action to cut wasteful expenditure and trim the fat, the Minister has introduced proposals for cost-cutting that will only reduce service delivery,” he said.
The Minister said he was referring specifically to the following:
- Provincial Equitable Share, the proportion of the budget allocated to provinces, will be reduced by R 4.7 billion;
- Provincial conditional grants, mainly Human Settlements and Education infrastructure, will be reduced by R 13.7 billion;
- Local Government grants will be reduced by R 16.1 billion conditional grants, which includes money for building schools, will be cut by R 13.9 billion;
- indirect grants by R 2.2 billion; and
- The police services will be reduced by 2 000 personnel.
The choice to cut funding for building schools and employing police officers will only put the futures and safety of our people at risk and is a terrible tradeoff, said Lees.
“The allocation of R57 billion over the medium term to fund poor students in higher education may seem like a step in the right direction. However, it is not sustainable and fails to address the true nature of the problem and the decades of chronic underfunding of this sector.
“Instead of stabilising the national debt levels, they will continue to rise to R 3.3 trillion over the next three years and debt service costs will amount to R 592 billion over the medium term.
“The once-off provisional allocation of R6 billion to drought relief is symptomatic of the short-term planning by National Government which lead to the current water crisis in the first place,” he said.
Yesterday the DA set out its own budget proposal, including the sale of assets such as parts of Eskom, which could save R112 billion and avoid tax increases.
“All in all, the Minister has failed to cut the fat and has opted instead to protect the few and reach into the pockets of poor South Africans to cover the cost,” said Lees.
AfriForum has hit out at Gigaba over free higher education, calling it nothing more than “politicking” and “doomed to failure”. The organisation pointed out that “a mere 5% of poor people obtain university exemption” and says that the money can be better spent by addressing the school system.
The ANC said it welcomed its minister’s “redistributive and people-centered budget”, particularly the allocation of almost R60 billion over the next three years to fund fee free higher education and training for children from poor and working class backgrounds.
"#Budget2018 is anti-poor.
The increase in VAT and the fuel levy will see the cost of food and travel increase significantly. The poor will be hardest hit."
— Democratic Alliance (@Our_DA) February 21, 2018
My only comment on the budget. Even the much hated Class of 1996 never increased VAT because they knew of its impact on the poor. The poor are not only those who receive social grants but working people who rely on basic foodstuffs for survival, looking after large families.
— Mbhazima Shilowa (@Enghumbhini) February 21, 2018
— Justice Malala (@justicemalala) February 21, 2018
OUTA's @wayneduv: "Society and the general taxpayer is sick and tired of seeing taxes increases year after year, with additional tax streams being introduced, while maladministration and corruption continues unabated." #BudgetSpeech2018
— OUTA (@OUTASA) February 21, 2018
— Chris Vick (@chrisvick3) February 21, 2018
The Speaker again protecting #StateCapture cronies.
Gigaba was found guilty of lying under oath & violating the Constitution while he was Minister of Home Affairs.
— Democratic Alliance (@Our_DA) February 21, 2018
If this is truly a new dawn, why must a disreputable, corrupt and unpatriotic Gigaba present the budget?#GigabaMustFall
— EFF (@EFFSouthAfrica) February 20, 2018
Just a friendly reminder that the smooth, shiny man on TV, entrusted to bring you the "tough" budget speech with its tax increases and infrastructure cuts, is the very same man who let the Guptas raid our SOEs for years. #NewDawn #BudgetSpeech2018 pic.twitter.com/RCN6byhx6e
— Jacques Maree (@JacquesMaree73) February 21, 2018